COMPLETE AAU Mr. AMERICA LISTING: 1939 through 1999: by Joe Roark
| DATE | WINNER | LOCATION | ||||
| 7/4/1939 | Roland Essmaker# | Chicago | IL | |||
| 5/25/1940 | John Grimek# | New York | NY | |||
| 5/24/1941 | John Grimek# | Philadelphia | PA | |||
| 5/24/1942 | Frank Leight# | Cincinnati | OH | |||
| 6/27/1943 | Jules Bacon | Los Angeles | CA | |||
| 5/27/1944 | Steve Stanko# | Chattanooga | TN | |||
| 6/3/1945 | Clarence Ross | Hollywood | CA | |||
| 6/2/1946 | Alan Stephan | Detroit | MI | |||
| 6/29/1947 | Steve Reeves# | Chicago | IL | |||
| 5/14/1948 | George Eiferman# | Los Angeles | CA | |||
| 5/22/1949 | Jack Delinger# | Cleveland | OH | |||
| 5/13/1950 | John Farbotnik# | Philadelphia | PA | |||
| 6/16/1951 | Roy Hilligenn | Los Angeles | CA | |||
| 6/28/1952 | Jim Park | New York | NY | |||
| 6/7/1953 | Bill Pearl | Indianapolis | IN | |||
| 6/26/1954 | Dick DuBois | Los Angeles | CA | |||
| 6/5/1955 | Steve Klisanin | Cleveland | OH | |||
| 6/2/1956 | Ray Schaefer | Philadelphia | PA | |||
| 6/23/1957 | Ron Lacy | Daytona Beach | FL | |||
| 6/21/1958 | Tom Sansone# | Los Angeles | CA | |||
| 8/1/1959 | Harry Johnson | York | PA | |||
| 6/12/1960 | Lloyd Lerille | Cleveland | OH | |||
| 6/24/1961 | Ray Routledge Jr | Santa Monica | CA | |||
| 6/3/1962 | Joe Abbenda | Detroit | MI | |||
| 6/29/1963 | Vern Weaver# | Harrisburg | PA | |||
| 6/14/1964 | Val Vasielieff | Chicago | IL | |||
| 6/12/1965 | Jerry Daniels | Los Angeles | CA | |||
| 6/19/1966 | Bob Gajda | York | PA | |||
| 6/10/1967 | Dennis Tinerino | Columbus | OH | |||
| 6/8/1968 | James Haislop | York | PA | |||
| 6/15/1969 | Boyer Coe | Chicago | IL | |||
| 6/14/1970 | Chris Dickerson | Culver City | CA | |||
| 6/12/1971 | Casey Viator | York | PA | |||
| 6/11/1972 | Steve Michalik | Detroit | MI | |||
| 6/10/1973 | James Morris | Williamsburg | VA | |||
| 6/9/1974 | Ron Thompson | York | PA | |||
| 6/22/1975 | Dale Adrian | Culver City | CA | |||
| 6/20/1976 | Kal Szkalak | Philadelphia | PA | |||
| 7/16/1977 | Dave Johns# | Santa Monica | CA | |||
| 9/2/1978 | Tony Pearson | Cincinnati | OH | |||
| 9/8/1979 | Ray Mentzer# | Atlanta | GA | |||
| 9/6/1980 | Gary Leonard | Santa Monica | CA | |||
| 9/5/1981 | Tim Belknap | Las Vegas | NV | |||
| 8/21/1982 | Rufus Howard | Worcester | MA | |||
| 9/3/1983 | Jeff King | Tampa | FL | |||
| 9/1/1984 | Joe Meeko | Pasadena | CA | |||
| 8/25/1985 | Michael Antorino | St. Louis | MO | |||
| 9/27/1986 | Glenn Knerr | Dallas | TX | |||
| 9/26/1987 | Richard Barretta | Atlantic City | NJ | |||
| 9/24/1988 | Bill Norberg | Tucson | AZ | |||
| 9/16/1989 | Matt DuFresne | Worcester | MA | |||
| 10/6/1990 | Pete Miller | Chicago | IL | |||
| 10/5/1991 | Joe DeAngelis | Atlantic City | NJ | |||
| 9/25/1992 | Mike Scarcella | Cherry Hill | NJ | |||
| 10/2/1993 | Billy Nothaft | Fort Myers | FL | |||
| 10/1/1994 | Andrew Sivert | Philadelphia | PA | |||
| 10/28/1995 | Terry Hairston | Fairfax | VA | |||
| 9/14/1996 | Doug Reiser | Fairfax | VA | |||
| 10/11/1997 | Bill Davey | Orlando | FL | |||
| 11/7/1998 | Harvey Campbell | Cocoa Beach | FL | |||
| 12/11/1999 | Tracey Dorsey | Fort Lee | VA | |||
| # denotes deceased | ||||||
| The AAU discontinued physique contests as of Jan 1, 2000;Special thanks to | ||||||
| John Rieger and Ted Karnezis for supplying some late 1990s info. | ||||||